Opinions from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2002

ordered by date

---

December 17, 2002

• 1 No. 158: In the Matter of George T., A Person Alleged to be a Juvenile Delinquent v. Presentment Agency
• 1 No. 173 SSM 18: Carlos Marcano v. The City of New York, et al.
• 1 No. 159: The People &c. v. Terick James, a/k/a Issac Delay
• 3 No. 155: In the Matter of the Arbitration Between City of Johnstown v. Association
• 2 No. 154: The People &c. v. Jared Carr-El, also known as Jared Carrel

December 12, 2002

• 4 No. 162: The People &c. v. Carl Gee
• 1 No. 157: The People &c. v. Charles Jackson
• 4 No. 161: Melissa Jean Mosher-Simons, on behalf of and as Administrator of the Estate of Jarrett Thomas Eck, Deceased, et al. v. County of Allegany
• 1 No. 163: Eva Diaz v. New York Downtown Hospital
• 2 No. 170: Steve Pierre v. Providence Washington Insurance Company
• USCOA,2 No. 179: Mark A. Varrichio and Associates, Mark A. Varrichio, Individually v. Chicago Insurance Company
• 1 No. 172 SSM 17: Caj Haller Pinero v. Rite Aid of New York, Inc.

November 21, 2002

• 2 No. 149: In the Matter of Raquel M., A Person Alleged to be a Juvenile Delinquent v.
• 3 No. 150: Francisco Sanchez v. State of New York
• 1 No. 151: The People &c. v. Dario Berroa
• 3 No. 152: The People &c. v. Lawrence D. Harris, a/k/a "Dahu", a/k/a "D"
• No. 175: v.
• 1 No. 133: In the Matter of Anne Gilman v. New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal et al.
• 1 No. 139: Continental Insurance Company, &c. v. The State of New York

November 19, 2002

• 5601d No. 137: Ned S. Church, an Infant, by Wendy Smith, &c., et al. v. Callanan Industries Inc.
• 4 No. 143: Susan McCoy v. Kenneth I. Feinman, &c., et al.
• 1 No. 147: Nissho Iwai Europe PLC v. Korea First Bank
• 1 No. 146: The People &c. v. Emilio Roque
• 1 No. 145: The People &c. v. Robbie Pines
• 1 No. 144: The People &c. v. Jose Mundo

November 14, 2002

• 3 No. 135: In the Matter of Perry Orens v. Antonia C. Novello, as Commissioner of the Department of Health of the State of New York, et al.
• 1 No. 138: Bruce Nagel et al. v. D & R Realty Corp.
• 1 No. 140: The People &c. v. Rodney Samuels
• 1 No. 148: The People &c v. Jerome Thompson
• 1 No. 134: The State of New York v.

October 24, 2002

• CoCt No. 130: The People &c. v. Terry Hitchcock
• 2 No. 129: In the Matter of Al Turi Landfill, Inc. v. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation et al.
• 1 No. 110: Midori Shimamoto, &c., et al. v. S&F Warehouses, Inc., et al.
• 1 No. 116: The People &c. v. George Gonzalez

October 22, 2002

• 1 No. 113: Rhonda Weingarten, &c., et al. v. Board of Trustees of the New York City Teachers' Retirement System, et al.
• 3 No. 109: In the Matter of Council of The City of New York v. Public Service Commission of the State of New York, et al.
• 2 No. 108: Mark Fisher et al. v. Qualico Contracting Corp.
• 2 No. 120: The People &c. v. Hilberto Ramos
• 4 No. 127: The People &c. v. Shakiya Robinson

October 17, 2002

• 3 No. 171 SSM 16: Dennis Lamp v. County of Cortland et al.
• 4 No. 126: In the Matter of Mendon Ponds Neighborhood Association et al. v. Richard Dehm, Chairman, et al.
• 4 No. 124: The People &c. v. Pete Nicholas, a/k/a Pete Nichols
• 1 No. 123: The People &c. v. Ronald Jackson
• 1 No. 114: Ronnie Greenfield, et al. v. Philles Records, Inc., et al.

October 15, 2002

• 1 No. 105: In the Matter of City of New York v. The State of New York et al.
• 1 No. 111: In the Matter of the Grand Jury Investigation in New York County. New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation v. Robert M. Morgenthau, &c.
• 2 No. 112: In the Matter of Emil Albano v. Board of Trustees of New York City Fire Department, Article II Pension Fund
• 2 No. 115: In the Matter of Citibank, N.A. v. Prime Motor Inns Limited Partnership, et al.
• 2 No. 125: The People &c. v. Charles Collins
• 4 No. 132: The People &c. v. Jayson Davidson

October 10, 2002

• 2 No. 106: In the Matter of New York City Transit Authority v. Transport Workers Union of America, &c., et al.
• 1 No. 118: The People &c. v. Philip D'Angelo
• AppT No. 119: The People &c. v. Lynette Cooper
• SCJC No. 122: In the Matter of Honorable Kenneth W. Gibbons, Justice of the Glenville Town Court, Schenectady County. Petitioner, For Review of a Determination of State Commission on Judicial Conduct v.
• No. 121: Nydia Hernandez, et al. v. Marva Hammons, &c.

September 17, 2002

• No. 104: v.
• No. 103: v.
• USCOA,2 No. 142: Tri-State Employment Services, Inc. v. The Mountbatten Surety Company, Inc.
• 3 No. 89: Town of Massena v. Healthcare Underwriters Mutual Insurance Company et al.
• CoCt No. 169 SSM 13: The People &c. v. Michael G. Blair

September 9, 2002

• 1 No. 168 SSM 15: In the Matter of Pedro Espada, Jr., et al. v. Ruben Diaz, &c., et al.
• 1 No. 168 SSM 15: In the Matter of Pedro Espada, Jr., et al. v. Ruben Diaz, &c., et al.

August 30, 2002

• 3 No. 164: In the Matter of Franz N. Stoppenbach, Jr. v. John E. Sweeney
• 1 No. 165: In the Matter of Peter M. Rivera, et al. v. Pedro Espada, Jr.
• 1 No. 166: In the Matter of Louise E. Dankberg, et al. v. Christopher B. Spuches
• 3 No. 167: In the Matter of Phyllis Bourges, et al. v. Kenneth P. Le Blanc, &c.

August 28, 2002

• No. 102: v.

July 9, 2002

• 1 No. 69: Ahmed Dame Toure v. Avis Rent A Car Systems, Inc. et al.
• 2 No. 70: The People &c. v. Oswaldo Sanche
• 3 No. 89: Town of Massena v. Healthcare Underwriters Mutual Insurance Company et al.
• SupC No. 80: The People &c. v. Darrel K. Harris
• 1 No. 98: In the Matter of Westchester Creek Corporation v. New York City School Construction Authority

July 2, 2002

• CoCt No. 90: The People &c. v. Joseph Smietana
• 4 No. 91: The People &c. v. Alexander J. Molnar
• 3 No. 87: George Firth v. State of New York
• 3 No. 88: Ryan A. Slayko v. Security Mutual Insurance Company
• 1 No. 92: Paul A. Goshen, &c. v. The Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York et al.

July 1, 2002

• SCJC No. 83: In the Matter of Honorable Elizabeth A. Shanley, Justice of the Esopus Town Court, Ulster County, Petitioner, For Review of a Determination of State Commission on Judicial Conduct v.
• 4 No. 97: The People &c. v. Charlie Hicks
• 2 No. 86: In the Matter of P.M.S. Assets, Ltd. v. Zoning Board of Appeals of Village of Pleasantville
• 2 No. 85: In the Matter of Retail Property Trust v. Board of Zoning Appeals of Town of Hempstead
• 2 No. 84: In the Matter of Philippe Ifrah v. W. Charles Utschig, Jr., et al.
• USCOA,2 No. 101: Stanley Murdza v. Robert Zimmerman

June 13, 2002

• 2 No. 77: The People &c. v. Kevin Jenkin
• AppT No. 99 SSM 10: The People &c. v. Gary Schaum
• 1 No. 79: Josephine Chianese v. Werner Meier et al.
• 1 No. 76: In the Matter of Newsday, Inc. v. Empire State Development Corporation
• 1 No. 61: The People &c. v. Jose Hernandez

June 11, 2002

• 1 No. 64: The People &c. v. Michael Arroyo
• 1 No. 65: The People &c. v. Charles Lineberger
• 1 No. 68: et al. v. Jennifer Realty Co., &c., et al.
• 1 No. 71: Jermaine Worrell Plummer, &c., et al. v. New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation
• 3 No. 100 SSM 11: In the Matter of Joseph T. Bojarczuk v. Richard P. Mills, as Commissioner of Education of the State of New York, et al.

June 6, 2002

• 2 No. 66: Kenneth P. LaValle, et al. v. Carl T. Hayden, et al.
• 3 No. 67: The People &c. v. William "II"
• 2 No. 73: In the Matter of Margret Dreikausen, et al. v. Zoning Board of Appeals of the City of Long Beach, et al.
• 3 No. 74: In the Matter of Maxine Davis v. Richard P. Mills, as Commissioner of Education of the State of New York, et al.
• 1 No. 96 SSM 9: The People &c. v. Edwin Tosca

June 4, 2002

• 1 No. 62: The State of New York v. The Seventh Regiment Fund, Inc.
• 2 No. 63: Violeta Espinal v. Melville Snow Contractors, Inc.
• 1 No. 75: The People &c. v. Andre Arnold
• AppT No. 72: The People &c. v. Bedros Yavru-Sakuk
• 1 No. 78: The People &c. v. Ramon Roche
• 3 No. 82 SSM 12: The People &c. v. Donald W. Wright

May 7, 2002

• 1 No. 19: The People &c. v. Cyrus Wolf
• 1 No. 38: Indosuez International Finance B.V. v. National Reserve Bank
• AppT No. 40: The People &c. v. Bulmaro Hernandez
• 4 No. 42: Mark J. Mahoney, et al. v. George E. Pataki, as Governor of the State of New York, et al.
• 3 No. 53: In the Matter of Diana Gravlin v. Heinz Ruppert

May 2, 2002

• 1 No. 55: The People &c. v. Tony Brown
• 2 No. 49: The People &c. v. Thomas Gilmour
• 1 No. 39: Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc. v. Allstate Insurance Company, et al.
• 1 No. 36: Banque Indosuez v. Sopwith Holdings Corp., et al.

April 30, 2002

• 2 No. 43: The People &c. v. Keith Campbell, a/k/a Leroy Miller
• USCOA,2 No. 46: Allstate Insurance Company, Government Employees Insurance Company, GEICO Casualty Company, GEICO General Insurance Company and GEICO Indemnity Co. v. Gregory V. Serio, in his capacity as Acting Superintendent of Insurance of t
• 3 No. 50: In the Matter of William C. Brandon v.
• 2 No. 51: John August v. New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company
• 2 No. 54: R/S Associates et al. v. New York Job Development Authority
• 2 No. 58: The People &c. v. Imanu Farrow, a/k/a Imanu Flowers

April 25, 2002

• 2 No. 41: In the Matter of John Brady v. Department of Motor Vehicles et al.
• 1 No. 44: The People &c. v. Eddy Abad
• 1 No. 45: The People &c. v. Robert Maldonado
• 2 No. 47: In the Matter of Carol Aurecchione v. New York State Division of Human Rights, et al.
• 2 No. 48: The People &c. v. Lee Woods
• USCOA,2 No. 52: Thomas Baker, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Health Management Systems, Inc., et al. v. Phillip Siegel

March 26, 2002

• No. 59: v.
• No. 35: v.
• 1 No. 29: Bluebird Partners, L.P. v. First Fidelity Bank, N.A., et al.
• 5601d No. 21: Keith Bauer v. The Female Academy of the Sacred Heart

March 21, 2002

• 4 No. 22: The People &c. v. Bart Alexander
• 1 No. 60 SSM 5: The People &c. v. Juan Orengo
• 1 No. 27: In the Matter of Walter Sakow, as de facto Executor &c. of Max Sakow, Deceased. Walter Sakow v. Diana Sakow et al.
• 4 No. 28 SSM 6: Barbara W. Wisholek et al. v. Gary Douglas, M.D.

March 19, 2002

• 5601d No. 25: Anthony Roberts et al. v. General Electric Company
• 4 No. 23: The People &c. v. Quintin Chambers
• 2 No. 17: James Summerville v. City of New York
• 1 No. 14: The People &c. v. Tarkisha Brown

March 14, 2002

• 3 No. 18: In the Matter of Herbert I. White v. County of Cortland
• 1 No. 20: The People &c. v. Vincent Williams
• 4 No. 24: The People &c. v. Marva Horne
• 4 No. 26: In the Matter of Arthur T. Farber v. City of Utica and Barbara B. Barry, &c.
• 2 No. 57: In the Matter of Larry Delgado v. Carolee Sunderland, &c., et al.

February 19, 2002

• 3 No. 3: The People &c. v. Eric More, a/k/a Brian Smith
• 2 No. 16: In the Matter of Anonymous for Admission to the Bar of the State of New York v.
• 2 No. 15: Shauna Alami, &c. v. Volkswagen of America, Inc.
• Mo. No. 118 : The People &c. v. Stephen LaValle

February 14, 2002

• 4 No. 12: Nancy Nestorowich, &c. as Executrix of the Estate of Walter S. Nestorowich, Deceased v. John J. Ricotta, M.D.
• 4 No. 13: The People &c. v. Mamoun Deis
• 1 No. 4: N. X. v. Cabrini Medical Center
• 3 No. 9: The People &c. v. Gordon M. Mower

February 13, 2002

• 4 No. 2: The People &c. v. Remus Smith
• 1 No. 10: Mark DiCintio v. DaimlerChrysler Corporation et al.
• 1 No. 34 SSM 1: Spiridou Meis et al. v. ELO Organization, LLC, et al.
• 2 No. 5: In the Matter of David B. (Anonymous) v. Commissioner of the New York State Office of Mental Health, et al.

February 7, 2002

• 3 No. 11: In the Matter of RLI Insurance Company, Surety Division v. New York State Department of Labor, et al.
• 3 No. 1: The People &c. v. Percival F. Hayes
• 2 No. 8: The People &c. v. Keith Brady
• 4 No. 7 SSM 20: In the Matter of Jeffrey M. Winkelman v. Kelly A. Furey
• 3 No. 33 SSM 21: Town of Conklin v. Douglas Ritter

January 22, 2002

• No. 32: v.

January 15, 2002

• 2 No. 31 SSM 18: Anthony Baisi et al. v. Gustavo Gonzalez et al.

January 8, 2002

• 4 No. 30 SSM 19: In the Matter of Donna M. Will v. Frontier Central School District Board of Education